Normal view MARC view ISBD view

Proving non-fatal strangulation in family violence cases : a case study on the criminalisation of family violence Heather Douglas and Robin Fitzgerald

By: Douglas, Heather.
Contributor(s): Fitzgerald, Robin.
Material type: materialTypeLabelArticleSeries: International Journal of Evidence & Proof.Publisher: Sage, 2021Subject(s): COERCIVE CONTROL | CRIMINAL JUSTICE | DOMESTIC VIOLENCE | FAMILY VIOLENCE | INTIMATE PARTNER VIOLENCE | STRANGULATION | INTERNATIONAL | AUSTRALIAOnline resources: DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/13657127211036175 In: International Journal of Evidence & Proof, 2021, 25(4): 350-370Summary: Non-fatal strangulation is recognised as a common form of coercive control in violent relationships. Overwhelmingly it is perpetrated by men against women. It is dangerous both because of the immediate and serious injuries it can cause, and the risk of future violence associated with it. A discrete offence of non-fatal strangulation has been introduced in many countries. Queensland, Australia introduced a discrete non-fatal strangulation offence in 2016. While the offence is charged often, around half the non-fatal strangulation charges laid by police do not proceed. We spoke to prosecution and defence lawyers to better understand the evidential obstacles to successful prosecution. We found that the prosecution of the offence faces challenges common to family violence offences more broadly, despite it being a discrete physical act. Specifically, we found that the willingness of the victim to testify and the perception of the victim's credibility were key to successful prosecution. (Authors' abstract). Record #7454
No physical items for this record

International Journal of Evidence & Proof, 2021, 25(4): 350-370

Non-fatal strangulation is recognised as a common form of coercive control in violent relationships. Overwhelmingly it is perpetrated by men against women. It is dangerous both because of the immediate and serious injuries it can cause, and the risk of future violence associated with it. A discrete offence of non-fatal strangulation has been introduced in many countries. Queensland, Australia introduced a discrete non-fatal strangulation offence in 2016. While the offence is charged often, around half the non-fatal strangulation charges laid by police do not proceed. We spoke to prosecution and defence lawyers to better understand the evidential obstacles to successful prosecution. We found that the prosecution of the offence faces challenges common to family violence offences more broadly, despite it being a discrete physical act. Specifically, we found that the willingness of the victim to testify and the perception of the victim's credibility were key to successful prosecution. (Authors' abstract). Record #7454